Saying good-bye to nuclear (Germany)

By Spiegel Online International

Merkel takes first steps toward a future of renewables

When Angela Merkel declared a moratorium on nuclear energy after the recent disaster in Japan, critics accused her of playing politics. Now she appears to be serious. A national summit in Berlin has laid out a six-point plan to move Germany away from nuclear power.

The pledge came quickly. Just days after the earthquake and tsunami decimated Japan's northeastern coast on March 11 -- and triggered the ongoing nuclear catastrophe at the Fukushima power plant -- German Chancellor Angela Merkel promised to bring an end to nuclear power in Germany and accelerate the switch to renewables. Now, Merkel is taking initial steps toward that goal.

On Friday, Merkel met with governors of Germany's 16 states and two other cabinet ministers in Berlin. "I think we all want to move away from nuclear energy as quickly as possible and switch to renewables," she told the summit. She laid out a six-point plan and said one of the country's most important efforts over the next decade would be heavy investment in more efficient energy grids.

Germany currently relies on nuclear plants to cover 23 percent of its energy demand. Merkel's predecessor, Chancellor Gerhard Schröder, passed a law in 2002 to shutter these plants gradually, with the country to be nuclear free by 2022. But Merkel -- controversially -- reversed this phase-out last autumn.

Now, she is scrambling to reverse the reversal. She would like to see all nuclear plants in Germany shut down within 10 years. "Nuclear energy has no future in Germany," David McAllister, Merkel's party ally and the governor of the state of Lower Saxony, told the Süddeutsche Zeitung. "It's clear we need to implement the exit if we don't want to lose people's confidence."

Shares in leading energy firms like E.ON and RWE fell in advance of the meeting, against the trend of a rising stock market.

'True Energy Consensus'

Seven of Germany's oldest power plants were already taken off line last month, the result of a moratorium announced by Merkel in the wake of the growing problems at Fukushima. An eighth -- the problematic newer facility at Krümmel -- was also shut down. The capacity lost by those shutdowns is not to be replaced by increased activity at other plants.

Germany's opposition Social Democrats, led by Sigmar Gabriel, told SPIEGEL ONLINE on Friday that a true change in national policy would require "the participation of the parliament, all the states, the environmental movement, the business community, consumers, and the labor unions." What was important, he said -- and what Merkel is well aware of lacking -- was a "true energy consensus."

Economy Minister Rainer Brüderle told German radio on Friday that the new phase-out plan would cost consumers and taxpayers between €1 billion and €2 billion per year. Criticisms that it might actually cost up to €3 billion a year were dismissed by Brüderle as being "speculative."

Merkel's broad six-point plan, presented at the meeting on Friday, includes:

1. Expanding renewable energy. Investing in more wind, solar, and biomass energies will try to raise the renewable-energy share of Germany's total energy use -- from a baseline of 17 percent in 2010.
2. Expanding grids and storage. Building a much larger storage and delivery network for electricity -- particularly wind energy, which can be generated in the north but must be carried to the south -- will be a main focus.
3. Efficiency. The government hopes improve the heating efficiency of German buildings -- and reduce consumption -- by 20 percent over the next decade.
4. "Flexible power." The government wants to build more "flexible" power plants that can pick up slack from wind or solar energy when the weather fails to generate enough electricity during peak demand. The obvious source of "flexible power" for now, besides nuclear energy, is natural gas.
5. Research and development. The government will increase government support for research into better energy storage and more efficient grids to a total of €500 million between now and 2020.
6. Citizen involvement. The government wants to involve its sometimes-recalcitrant citizenry due to ongoing resistance against wind generators and the installation of an efficient new power line grid in some regions.

"Of course there will still be disagreements," Merkel told her state governors Friday. But by the end of the meeting she promised that her administration would bring a package of new firm proposals to parliament by the middle of June.

msm, with wires and reporting by Philipp Wittrock